Why you should use real collagen
A vegetarian or vegan lifestyle is in fashion.
Most people prefer this diet for ethical and/or health reasons, but if you want to benefit from the added health value of collagen, you can’t avoid animal products, because there is no such thing as plant collagen.
Collagen only in humans and animals
Collagen is a structural protein that is only produced by humans and multicellular animals. In humans, collagen makes up about 30% of the organism’s total protein. Collagen gives many tissues strength and elasticity. We find it in internal organs, veins, bones, joints, muscles, fascia, tendons and the skin.
Plants on the other hand, make tear-resistant fibres from cellulose, which are responsible for strength and elasticity. Plants can also make amino acids and proteins, but they do not make collagen.
Is there vegetarian or vegan collagen?
To meet consumer demand, there are now collagen products that advertise themselves as vegetarian or vegan. However, if you take a closer look at the products, you will see that they are not real collagen. Many of these products contain the amino acids from which collagen can be formed, but they do not contain collagen peptides. The effect of these products is explained, among other things, with micronutrients, such as vitamin C, which is necessary for collagen production. Thus, the administration of amino acids alone in conjunction with various micronutrients is supposed to be able to stimulate collagen formation. The problem with this argumentation is that it obviously does not work. How else can it be explained that people form less collagen with increasing age despite sufficient vitamin supply and the consumption of high-quality protein?
Label fraud
I was very surprised to read about a new, supposedly vegetarian collagen that is obtained from eggshell membranes by a special process. I don’t understand how such a product can be called vegetarian. For me, it is a labelling fraud. Even if the membranes are processed and no animal has lost its life, the fact is that the raw material is of animal origin and the end product contains processed animal proteins.
Also new on the market are collagens, which are described as vegan and are produced synthetically by fermentation with yeasts or bacteria. If you look more closely, you will find only vague formulations about the exact composition and structure of the proteins obtained in this way. They are obviously not an exact replica of the various collagens of animal origin.
Vegetarian and vegan is not a real alternative.
We now know from scientific research and studies that extremely small collagen peptides pass through the stomach unharmed and are absorbed into the blood via active transport in the intestine. From there they reach the various target tissues. Such peptides are obtained by enzymatic cleavage from animal collagens of types I and III and consist of only two or three amino acids. Proven effects of these peptides include the stimulation of collagen production in the skin and joints as well as an anti-inflammatory effect. A comparable effect with products that call themselves vegan or vegetarian is not to be expected, as they are composed differently and do not have the same signalling effect for the metabolism.
My Tip:
I can very well understand the arguments against animal products. However, as a pharmacist, I am so convinced by the clinical data on the health benefits and added value of animal collagen that I am in favour of it and would recommend it to anyone who values their health. A flexitarian diet with collagen is therefore a good compromise for me compared to a strict vegetarian diet. What is important for me is that the raw materials come from responsible production. As a consumer, I have a choice and can opt for products that are transparent in this respect.
Pharmacist Andreas Binninger